Continuing our series of articles on quality management methodologies for SEO projects, it is worth taking a look at another interesting approach: total quality management (TQM). Previous articles have already discussed the Deming cycle (PDCA), Six Sigma, Lean, Kaizen and Agile/Scrum. TQM is another alternative to the standard OKR and PDCA methods that are the cornerstone of NON.agency operations.

What is Total Quality Management?

Total Quality Management (TQM) is a comprehensive philosophy of quality management that originated in Japan in the 1950s and spread around the world in the 1980s and 1990s. TQM assumes that quality is the responsibility of all members of an organization and encompasses all aspects of a company's operations.

The basic idea of TQM is to continuously improve processes to increase customer satisfaction and improve business performance. Unlike approaches that focus on specific methods or tools, TQM is a holistic organizational culture focused on quality.

Main principles of Total Quality Management

TQM is based on several key principles:

1. Customer orientation - Understanding and meeting customer needs is the most important goal
2. Involvement of all employees - Everyone in the organization is responsible for quality
3. Process approach - Focus on optimizing processes, not just end results
4. Continuous improvement - Constantly striving to improve all aspects of the business
5. Making decisions based on facts - Using data and analysis instead of intuition
6. A systems approach to management - Seeing the organization as an integrated system
7. Building mutually beneficial relationships with suppliers - Treating suppliers as partners

TQM in the context of SEO: Potential applications

1. comprehensive quality orientation in SEO

In the context of SEO, a TQM approach would mean taking a holistic view of the quality of all aspects of an SEO campaign:

• Quality of content
• Quality of technical elements of the website
• Quality of external links
• Quality of user experience
• Quality of reporting and communication with the customer

Instead of focusing on single indicators (e.g., items), TQM focuses on the big picture and the synergy of all elements.

2. whole team commitment to quality SEO

In the TQM approach to SEO, the responsibility for quality rests with all members of the team:

• SEO specialists are responsible for strategy and tactics
• Content managers for high quality content
• Developers for technical aspects
• UX designers behind user experience
• Account managers for customer communications

Each person in an SEO project understands how their work affects the overall quality of the service.

3. process management in SEO

TQM focuses on process optimization, which in the context of SEO can mean:

• Standardization of SEO audit processes
• Optimization of content production workflow
• Systematization of link building processes
• Improve reporting and communication processes

Documentation and standardization of SEO processes ensures consistency and predictability of results.

4. continuous improvement of SEO strategy

TQM involves continuous improvement of all processes. In SEO, this could include:

• Regular reviews and updates of SEO strategy
• Testing new approaches and tactics
• Implementing the latest practices and technologies
• Adapting to changes in search engine algorithms
• Systematic training of the team

5. making SEO decisions based on data

TQM has a strong emphasis on data analysis, which is a perfect fit for SEO:

• Detailed analysis of data from Google Analytics and Search Console
• Monitoring of SEO KPIs and metrics
• A/B testing different approaches
• Data-driven competitive analysis
• Advanced analytics for strategic decision making

An example of a TQM model in an SEO project

What might an SEO project run according to TQM principles look like? The following is a hypothetical model:

1. quality planning

• Identification of customer requirements and expectations
• Identification of key quality indicators (KQI)
• Develop a comprehensive SEO strategy focused on quality
• Establish quality assurance processes for all activities

2. quality assurance

• Standardization of SEO processes through SOPs (Standard Operating Procedures).
• Training and competence development of the team
• Internal audits of SEO activities
• Systematic quality reviews

3. quality control

• Regular measurement of results and KPIs
• Root cause analysis for quality problems
• Monitoring compliance with processes
• Collecting feedback from customers and end users

4. quality improvement

• Identification of areas for improvement
• Implementation of process improvements
• Innovations in SEO methods
• Benchmarking with industry best practices

Case study: TQM in an international SEO campaign

An example of effective application of TQM principles in SEO could be an international campaign for an e-commerce company operating in 10 European markets:

Challenge:

The company needed a consistent approach to SEO across all markets, while taking into account local specifics.

TQM approach:

1. Customer orientation
   
   • Conduct user research in each market
   • Analysis of local search behavior
   • Alignment of strategies with local preferences
2. Team commitment
   
   • Establishment of an international SEO team
   • Regular training and knowledge sharing
   • Shared responsibility for quality
3. Process approach
   
   • Standardization of SEO processes across all markets
   • Create common templates and documentation
   • Automation of repetitive tasks
4. Continuous improvement
   
   • Weekly improvement meetings
   • Sharing best practices between markets
   • Systematic testing of new approaches
5. Data-driven decisions
   
   • Advanced cross-market analytics
   • Dashboards comparing performance in different markets
   • Identification of patterns and trends

Results:

With a comprehensive TQM approach, the company could achieve:

• Increase organic visibility by 40-60% in all markets
• Significant improvement in conversion rates
• Reduction of operating costs through standardization
• Better adaptation to local conditions

TQM vs PDCA and OKR: A comparison of approaches.

How does TQM compare to the standard OKR and PDCA methodologies used in NON.agency?

Similarities:

• All approaches focus on continuous improvement
• All use data to make decisions
• All require regular review and adjustment of strategies

Differences:

• Scope: TQM is more holistic, encompassing the entire organizational culture, while PDCA focuses on improvement cycles and OKR on goals and results
• Complexity: TQM is more complex and may require more organizational changes
• Implementation: TQM usually requires longer implementation time and deeper cultural changes
• Flexibility: OKR and PDCA may be easier to adapt in smaller teams or projects

Advantages and challenges of TQM in SEO

Advantages:

• A holistic approach to SEO quality
• Involvement of the whole team in achieving results
• Standardization and optimization of processes
• Long-term perspective and stable results
• Strong end-customer orientation

Challenges:

• Requires significant management commitment
• Implementation can be time-consuming and costly
• More difficult to apply to smaller teams
• Can lead to excessive bureaucracy
• Requires a cultural change throughout the organization

Conclusions: Is TQM a good alternative to SEO project management?

Total Quality Management offers an interesting alternative to traditional SEO project management methods. Particularly for large organizations with extensive SEO activities, a comprehensive TQM approach can bring significant benefits.

However, implementing full TQM requires a significant investment of time and resources and deep organizational changes. For many SEO agencies and teams, it may be more practical to adapt selected elements of TQM within existing methodologies like PDCA or OKR.

Ultimately, the choice of the appropriate methodology should depend on the specific needs of the organization, the size of the team, the company's culture and customer expectations. Regardless of the chosen approach, the key is to consistently apply the chosen methodology and continuously improve processes.

‍