OKRs and PDCA: Creating a continuous improvement cycle in SEO

Welcome to the second article in our three-part series on implementing OKRs in SEO agencies. In the first article, we covered the basics of OKR and presented an implementation framework. Now we will look at how to integrate OKR with the PDCA cycle to create an effective continuous improvement system in SEO operations.

The power of combining OKR with PDCA

While OKRs help define what we want to achieve, the PDCA (Plan-Do-Check-Act, or Plan-Do-Check-Act) cycle provides a structured approach to continuously improving how we achieve those goals. This combination is particularly valuable in SEO, where algorithms, best practices and client needs are constantly evolving.

Let's look at how these methodologies work together:

OKR: Setting the direction

• Defining clear, ambitious goals
• Establish measurable key results
• Create cohesion around priorities
• Ensure transparency in the teams

PDCA: Creating a path

• Systematic improvement of processes
• Testing and learning from approaches
• Adapting to changing circumstances
• Building institutional knowledge

Understanding the PDCA cycle

The PDCA cycle, also known as the Deming Cycle, consists of four iterative steps:

1. Plan (Plan): Define the problem, analyze the data and develop a hypothesis.
2. Execute (Do): Implement the plan on a small scale or as a test.
3. Check (Check): Evaluate performance against objectives and key results.
4. Act: Standardize successful approaches or start the cycle again with new proposals.

‍

‍

At NON.agency, we have found that applying this cycle to our OKR process creates a powerful feedback loop that keeps us moving forward even in the complex and ever-changing world of SEO.

How to integrate OKR and PDCA?

Here's how we integrate these methodologies throughout the quarterly OKR cycle:

Planning phase (weeks 1-2)

PLAN

• Review of OKR's results from the previous quarter
• Identify strategic priorities for the coming quarter
• Development of OKRs for the company and teams
• Create detailed implementation plans for achieving key results

Implementation phase (weeks 3-10)

EXECUTE

• Implementation of planned activities
• Track progress on key outcomes
• Conduct weekly inspections
• Documenting challenges and insights

SEE

• Conduct mid-quarter reviews (Week 6-7)
• Assessment of progress against key results
• Identification of obstacles and opportunities
• Update forecasts based on current results

ACTION

• Adjusting approach based on mid-quarter findings
• Focusing on what works
• Changing the approach to what doesn't work
• Sharing lessons learned between teams

Closing phase (weeks 11-12)

SEE

• OKR rating (usually on a scale of 0 to 1.0)
• Analysis of results compared to targets
• Documenting key findings

ACTION

• Conducting retrospective sessions
• Identification of opportunities for improvement
• Application of applications to OKR for the next quarter

Reset phase (week 13)

PLAN

• Start planning OKR for next quarter
• Taking into account the conclusions of the previous cycle
• Adjusting ambition levels based on performance

PDCA in action for SEO campaigns - an example

Let's see how it works in SEO campaigns, with a detailed example:

Initial OKRs:

Goal: Transform the organic search results of customer X.

‍

Key Results:

1. increase organic traffic by 50%.

2. improve conversion rate from organic traffic by 20%.

3. Achieve first-page positions for 80% of priority keywords.

PDCA cycle 1:

PLAN:

• Conduct a comprehensive technical audit.
• Develop a content strategy for priority keywords.
• Create an implementation map with clear milestones.

EXECUTIVE:

• Implement critical technical fixes.
• Optimize existing content for top 20 keywords.
• Creating 5 new content targeting high intent keywords.

SEE ALSO:

• After 4 weeks: Organic traffic increased by 15%, conversion rate unchanged, positions improved for 30% of keywords.
• Key conclusion: technical improvements drive traffic growth, but do not improve conversion quality.

ACTION:

• Doubling efforts in technical optimizations.
• Changing content strategy to focus more on conversion intent.
• Adding user experience enhancements to landing pages.

PDCA cycle 2:

PLAN:

• Developing the second phase of technical improvements.
• Create a plan for conversion-oriented content optimization.
• Design A/B tests for landing pages.

EXECUTIVE:

• Implement the technical improvements from Phase 2.
• Optimization of 10 existing pages for conversion.
• Launching landing page tests.

SEE ALSO:

• After 8 weeks: Organic traffic increased by 35%, conversion rate increased by 10%, positions improved for 60% of keywords.
• Key conclusion: landing page tests show significant improvements in conversions for specific segments.

ACTION:

• Scale successful landing page elements to the entire site.
• Refine content targeting based on conversion data.
• Update key performance forecasts based on current trajectory.

End of quarter:

• Organic traffic increased by 42% (KR1: 84% achieved).
• The conversion rate improved by 22% (KR2: 110% achieved).
• 75% of priority keywords on the first page (KR3: 94% achieved).
• Overall OKR score: 0.96 (exceptional performance).

Essential tools for tracking OKR-PDCA integration

To effectively manage this integrated approach, you need appropriate tracking mechanisms:

1 OKR Scorecard

Create a central panel showing all OKRs and their current status:

‍

2 PDCA tracking template

Document your cycles of experimentation and learning:

‍

3. template for weekly inspections

Structure your weekly team meetings to keep the PDCA cycle moving:

Status update:

• Current progress in key results (with data)
• Activities completed last week
• Activities planned for this week

PDCA Discussion:

• What works well? (Check)
• What's not working? (Check)
• What adjustments should we make? (Act)
• Who will be responsible for these changes? (Plan for the next cycle)

The role of CFR in improving OKR and PDCA

An often overlooked component of effective OKR implementation is the CFR (Conversations, Feedback, Recognition) framework introduced by John Doerr in "Measure What Matters".

CFR complements OKR and PDCA by:

1. Discussions: Regular check-ins to discuss progress, obstacles and lessons learned.
2. Feedback: continuous, two-way feedback to refine approaches.
3. Recognition: Recognizing achievements and efforts to maintain momentum.

At NON.agency, we have integrated CFR into our OKR-PDCA process by:

• Weekly team review meetings structured around PDCA discussions.
• Monthly feedback sessions focused on process improvement.
• Quarterly recognition events celebrating both achievement and learning.

Typical challenges and solutions

Integrating OKRs with PDCA is not without its challenges. Here are some common problems and how to solve them:

Challenge 1: Going through PDCA cycles too fast

Solution: Establish a minimum time frame for each cycle (e.g., 2-4 weeks) to ensure sufficient data for evaluation.

Challenge 2: Stuck in analysis paralysis

Solution: set time limits for the "Check" phase and focus on actionable conclusions rather than perfect data.

Challenge 3: Failure to document requests

Solution: create a centralized "knowledge repository" where all teams document the findings from their PDCA cycles.

Challenge 4: Resistance to changing strategy in the middle of the quarter

Solution: Emphasize that the goal is to achieve key results, not perfect execution of the initial plan.

Challenge 5: OKRs become disconnected from daily operations

Solution: Use weekly PDCA checks to clearly link daily activities to key results.

OKR-PDCA implementation checklist

To effectively implement this integrated approach, make sure you have:

• Clearly defined OKRs for the company and each team.
• A structured template for documenting PDCA cycles.
• Weekly follow-up meetings that follow the PDCA format.
• Mid-quarter review sessions to assess progress and make adjustments.
• A system for tracking both OKR progress and PDCA findings.
• A knowledge repository for documenting insights.
• End-of-quarter retrospectives that influence planning for the next cycle.

Summary: How to build a learning organization?

By integrating OKRs with PDCA, your SEO agency can become what Peter Senge calls a "learning organization "-that is, one that continually transforms itself through systematic experimentation and adaptation.

This integrated approach creates a powerful virtuous cycle:

1. OKRs provide clear direction and measurable goals.
2. PDCA offers a structured approach to achieving these goals.
3. Each cycle generates conclusions that inform the next set of OKRs.
4. The organization is becoming more effective in achieving ambitious goals.

In our third and final article in this series, we'll look at examples from real-world OKR implementations at SEO agencies, including detailed case studies, templates and advanced strategies for scaling this approach as organizations grow.

‍